Ninja Foodi vs Instant Pot Air Fryer: Multi-Cooker Mega-Test
If you're looking to save precious counter space and want one appliance that can potentially do it all – from pressure cooking and slow cooking to steaming, sautéing, and of course, air frying – you're likely considering a Ninja Foodi multi-cooker or an Instant Pot with an air fryer lid attachment (or a model with an integrated air fry function like the Duo Crisp). Both promise impressive versatility, offering a blend of popular cooking methods. But how do they truly compare, especially when it comes to their air frying capabilities within a multi-cooker format? Here’s a hands-on look to help you see which one might be the best all-in-one choice for your kitchen.
Share This Comparison & Connect With Us:
Product Overview & Design Philosophy
The fundamental difference between Ninja Foodi multi-cookers with air fry and Instant Pot models with air fry capability often lies in their integrated design vs. modularity:
- Ninja Foodi: Often referred to as an “all-in-one cooking machine,” the Foodi line typically integrates multiple popular functions, most notably pressure cooking and air frying (along with other functions like steaming, slow cooking, searing/sautéing, baking, broiling) within a single unit. Many popular models feature two distinct lids – one for pressure cooking/slow cooking that is removable, and one for air frying/other methods that is often hinged and attached. This integrated design means less swapping between *types* of appliances, but the hinged lid can be bulky and require overhead clearance.
- Instant Pot + Air Fryer Lid: This approach adds air frying capability to a standard Instant Pot pressure cooker. Some Instant Pot models come specifically bundled with a dedicated air fryer lid alongside the standard pressure cooking lid (like the Duo Crisp or Pro Crisp models). Alternatively, owners of existing standard Instant Pot models can sometimes buy a separate air fryer lid attachment to add air frying to their current appliance. This design requires physically swapping between the pressure cooking lid and the air fryer lid between cooking stages, and each lid needs its own storage space.
The fundamental difference in design directly impacts usability and how seamlessly you can switch between functions like pressure cooking (e.g., to tenderize) and air frying (e.g., to crisp up a finish).
Features Side-by-Side: What They Offer
Here’s a breakdown of common features and performance points when comparing typical Ninja Foodi multi-cookers with air fry function to Instant Pot models with air fry capability (either integrated lid or separate lid):
| Feature | Ninja Foodi Multi-Cooker | Instant Pot + Air Fry Lid |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Functions Integrated | Pressure Cook, Air Fry, Slow Cook, Sear/Sauté, Steam, Bake, Broil, Dehydrate (Functions vary by model) | Pressure Cook, Slow Cook, Sauté, Steam, Yogurt, Keep Warm (Base Pot); Air Fry, Roast, Bake, Broil, Dehydrate (Air Fry Lid Functions vary by lid/model) |
| Air Fry Performance | Very good for a multi-cooker, aims for results similar to a dedicated air fryer but often limited by the shape/size of the inner cooking pot. Uses a basket or rack accessory inside the pot. | Good air frying performance, but the basket shape/size used with the air fryer lid can be shallower/wider, which may affect cooking capacity or require different layering/shaking compared to dedicated units. Results are typically good, but perhaps slightly less intense crisping than a dedicated air fryer (see buying guide) or some Foodi models. |
| Pressure Cooker Performance | Excellent, cooks food quickly under pressure. | Excellent (core Instant Pot functionality), widely praised for speed and reliability in pressure cooking. |
| Capacity | Commonly available in 6 qt, 8 qt, and larger sizes for the inner cooking pot. Usable air frying capacity within the pot depends on the specific air frying basket or rack accessory included with the model. | Base Instant Pot capacity commonly 6 qt or 8 qt. Usable air frying capacity depends on the specific basket accessory used with the air fryer lid, typically matching the diameter of the pot but being shallower. |
| Lid Management | Often features two lids (a removable pressure & slow cooker lid, and a hinged air fry & crisping lid) or a complex integrated lid. Requires careful handling and storage of the lid not currently in use, or managing clearance for the hinged lid. | Requires physically swapping between the standard pressure cooker lid and the air fryer lid between cooking stages or functions. Each lid is bulky and needs its own separate storage space. |
| User Interface | Digital control panel with clear function buttons and presets. Generally intuitive once the different lids/modes and their associated functions are understood. | Digital panel on the base Instant Pot for its functions. The air fryer lid has its *own* separate digital interface and controls. Requires learning two potentially different sets of controls or displays. |
| Seamless Function Switching | Generally more integrated and seamless as the functions are built into one appliance. Less physical swapping required on models with dual lids, allowing for smoother transitions (e.g., pressure cook then flip lid to air fry). | Requires manually removing one lid and attaching the other to switch between pressure cooking/slow cooking and air frying. Less seamless for recipes that require alternating between methods. |
| Accessories | Usually includes a cooking pot, often a reversible rack, and a specific air frying basket or crisping tray designed to fit inside the pot. | Includes the cooking pot and racks/baskets specific to the air fryer lid designed to fit inside the pot. Requires managing and storing multiple lids and accessories. |
Pros & Cons
Let's look at the advantages and disadvantages of each approach:
Ninja Foodi Multi-Cooker with Air Fry Check Price on Amazon
Pros:
- Offers a true sense of an “all-in-one” appliance, particularly for recipes that involve both pressure cooking and finishing with air frying (e.g., cooking ribs or whole chickens). The transition between functions is often more seamless.
- Air frying performance is generally very good for a multi-cooker format, often achieving a solid level of crispness that is satisfying for most users.
- Models with two lids reduce the need for physical lid swapping between pressure cook/slow cook and air fry functions, compared to separate lids.
- Comes with all necessary accessories for advertised functions included in one package.
- Can potentially save counter space by consolidating multiple appliances into one unit (pressure cooker, air fryer, slow cooker, etc.).
Cons:
- Can have a large countertop footprint and might be quite tall, requiring significant vertical clearance, especially models with a bulky hinged air fryer lid.
- Generally positioned at a higher price point than purchasing a standard Instant Pot model or adding a separate Instant Pot air fryer lid.
- While air frying is good, it won't typically match the intense, rapid crisping power of a dedicated, high-end basket-style air fryer.
- Managing the integrated/dual lids or the large hinged lid can be inconvenient for storage or use under cabinets.
- Cleanup involves washing the inner pot, basket, and sometimes the lid components (see cleaning guide).
Instant Pot with Air Fryer Lid Check Price on Amazon
Pros:
- Allows existing Instant Pot owners to "upgrade" their current standard pot to include air frying capability without buying a whole new base appliance (if purchasing the separate lid accessory).
- Models bundled with an air fryer lid often come at a more accessible price point when compared directly to some high-end, similarly sized multi-cookers like the Foodi.
- Retains the core Instant Pot strengths, including often superior pressure cooking capabilities and dedicated functions like yogurt making that not all Foodi models have.
- The base pot functions and controls are the same familiar Instant Pot unit for standard pressure/slow cooking.
Cons:
- Requires physically swapping between the standard pressure cooker lid and the air fryer lid, which can be cumbersome during cooking and requires separate storage space for the unused lid.
- The air fry basket accessory used with the lid can sometimes be shallower or shaped differently than baskets in dedicated air fryers or Foodi models, potentially limiting capacity for certain foods or requiring more shaking/flipping.
- Air frying performance is generally good, but may not consistently reach the same level of intense crispness as a dedicated air fryer or potentially some Foodi models.
- Managing and cleaning two different lids and their associated accessories adds complexity compared to a single-function appliance.
- Requires ensuring the air fryer lid is compatible with your specific Instant Pot model if buying separately.
Which Multi-Cooker with Air Fry Function is Right For You?
Choosing between a Ninja Foodi multi-cooker with air fry and an Instant Pot with air fry capability depends heavily on your primary cooking needs, budget, and preferred workflow:
- Choose Ninja Foodi if: You frequently cook recipes that combine pressure cooking and air frying steps and you want the most integrated, seamless experience for switching between them. You are willing to pay a potentially higher price for this convenience and prioritize solid air frying performance within a multi-cooker format.
- Choose Instant Pot with Air Fryer Lid if: You already own a compatible Instant Pot and want to add air frying capability without buying a whole new base appliance (by purchasing the separate lid). You value a lower entry price (when purchasing a bundled model) or prioritize Instant Pot's core strengths like pressure cooking consistency and specific functions like yogurt making, and you don't mind manually swapping lids between cooking methods.
Both approaches offer excellent value for consolidating multiple appliances into one countertop footprint. However, it's important to remember that for dedicated, peak air frying performance, neither multi-cooker will typically outperform a dedicated, high-end basket-style air fryer.
Consider which functions you'll use most often (is it primarily pressure cooking + occasional air fry, or frequent combination cooking?) and whether the lid management is a significant concern for your kitchen space and workflow. Our Top 10 Air Fryers List and Buying Guide feature popular models and discuss integrated vs. dedicated appliance approaches.
Conclusion: Versatile Appliances for Modern Kitchens
The Ninja Foodi multi-cooker with air fry and the Instant Pot with air fry capabilities are both impressive, versatile appliances that combine popular cooking methods into one unit. Ninja often provides a more integrated, seamless experience for multi-step recipes, while the Instant Pot system offers flexibility for existing owners and often a lower entry price point. By understanding their specific designs, features, and performance nuances, you can select the multi-cooker that best fits your cooking style, space limitations, and budget, bringing powerful multi-functional cooking (including air frying) to your countertop.